
At a glance
- Section 8.3 of the shared Code asks for records that are accurate, up-to-date, factual, objective and legible.
- Sign only reports and certificates you believe to be accurate, and check the content before you sign.
- Good medical practice says any change or addition to a medical record should be dated, including in an electronic record.
- An error you correct openly is not dishonesty; concealment, or a statement you knew was untrue, is a probity concern.
- A partial account given to a regulator becomes a second probity concern.
Probity means being honest and trustworthy in all professional dealings, including records, claims, declarations, reports and communication with regulators. This guide is for Australian healthcare professionals who want to know what the word covers, where it appears in the codes of conduct and what happens when honesty is in question. It is part of our topic page on professional misconduct.
If a probity concern has been raised about you, our Probity and Honesty for Healthcare Professionals (our probity and honesty course after an Ahpra complaint) course gives a dated certificate you can use as remediation and record as CPD. It is A$200 (A$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours. Every course is on our courses for an Ahpra notification page.
What probity in healthcare covers
The word probity does not appear as a heading in the codes, but honesty runs through them. Principle 8 of the shared Code of conduct (June 2022) says professional behaviour “includes practising ethically and honestly”. The parts of the shared Code that set out what honesty means in practice are:
| Area | What the shared Code of conduct asks |
|---|---|
| Health records (8.3) | Records that are accurate, up-to-date, factual, objective and legible, made at the time of events or as soon as possible afterwards |
| Reports and certificates (8.7) | Be honest and not misleading, sign only documents you believe to be accurate, and take reasonable steps to check the content before you sign |
| Fees and money (8.11) | Be honest and transparent in financial arrangements with patients, do not exploit a patient’s lack of knowledge, and be transparent in dealings with employers and insurers |
| Investigations (8.9) | Cooperate with any legitimate inquiry, including by giving accurate, honest information when asked |
| Patients (3.2, 4.1) | Communicate with patients honestly as well as courteously and respectfully |
The Medical Board’s Good medical practice sets out the same duties for doctors: accurate records made at the time (10.5), honest reports and certificates (10.9), and honesty and transparency in financial arrangements (10.13). It adds that any change or addition to a medical record should be dated, including in an electronic record (10.5.6). Nurses and midwives should read the NMBA’s codes for their own wording.
Probity concerns that reach Ahpra
A probity concern is any concern that a practitioner has not been honest. Examples include:
- adding to or changing a record after an incident without dating the change;
- signing a certificate or report without checking that it is accurate;
- a claim to an insurer or funder for a service that was not provided as described;
- an answer on the Ahpra renewal declaration that leaves out something you had to declare;
- a misleading statement in a CV or work history (8.8 of the shared Code covers your work history);
- an account to Ahpra or a Board during an investigation that is not accurate or complete.
Small mistakes are not dishonesty. An error you correct openly, and record as a correction, is a different matter from a record changed to hide what happened. What turns an error into a probity concern is concealment, or a statement you knew was untrue.
How the Boards view dishonesty
Honesty goes to the trust that registration depends on. Principle 8 of the shared Code says practitioners must show “a standard of professional behaviour that warrants the trust and respect of the community”, and the Code’s values apply to conduct in every setting. A finding about dishonesty can be about professional conduct rather than clinical skill, and the outcome depends on what happened, whether it was repeated and what you have done since.
The National Law has more than one level of finding. Our guide on the difference between unsatisfactory professional conduct and professional misconduct explains how they differ, and which panel or tribunal decides each one.
If you have received a notification that alleges dishonesty, our guide facing an Ahpra notification for dishonesty? explains what Ahpra looks at and what to do first.
Restoring trust after a probity concern
Restoring trust after a probity concern means showing that you understand why honesty matters, not only that you regret what happened. That comes down to three things:
- A full and honest account. Section 8.9 of the shared Code asks for accurate, honest information when an inquiry asks for it. A partial account given to a regulator becomes a second probity concern.
- Insight. Say what you did, why it was wrong and who it affected. Our guide How to demonstrate insight to Ahpra explains what to write.
- Evidence of change. A changed process, such as checking every certificate before signing, an audit of your own records or a second check on billing, and a dated certificate from a remediation course.
If there is no notification and you want to strengthen your practice, the same course counts as CPD. Record what you learned and how you will apply it.
If you would rather work through a probity concern live with a facilitator, our guide Face-to-Face Ahpra Probity Course: What Happens on the Day explains how the live day runs.
If you are facing a dishonesty allegation now, our guide How an Ahpra Probity Course Helps After a Dishonesty Allegation explains how a probity course fits into your response and your CPD.
Sources and further reading
- Code of conduct (shared Code of conduct, June 2022)
- Medical Board of Australia: Good medical practice, a code of conduct for doctors in Australia
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for an Ahpra dishonesty or probity concern? Our Ahpra course for this is written for health practitioners and follows your National Board's code of conduct; pair it with a reflective statement that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my Ahpra notification? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which Ahpra and your National Board look at — strongest with a reflective statement and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflective statement? With your written response to the notification — or before a panel, tribunal or a review of conditions if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Australia, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
Is a small error a probity issue?
Not by itself. Australian healthcare professionals make errors, and the codes ask for accurate records and honest reports, not perfect ones. An error becomes a probity issue when it is hidden, when a record is changed without dating the change, or when you knew a statement was untrue. Correct errors openly and record the correction.
Does probity cover private life?
It can. The shared Code of conduct says its values apply to conduct in every setting, and that practitioners must act in accordance with the law in their personal and professional lives. Australian healthcare professionals should also note that some events outside work, such as being charged with certain offences, must be reported to Ahpra.
What course covers probity?
Our Probity and Honesty for Healthcare Professionals course covers honesty in records, reports, fees and dealings with regulators. It is A$200 (A$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, with a dated certificate that Australian healthcare professionals can use as remediation after a notification or record as CPD.
Is probity only about money?
No. Money is one part, and the shared Code of conduct asks for honesty and transparency in financial arrangements. Probity also covers health records, reports and certificates, declarations to Ahpra and the information you give during an investigation.
This article is published by Healthcare Ethics Australia for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnity insurer, professional association or a lawyer about your own matter.